If you watch anime regularly, a tracking site is essential for keeping up with seasonal shows, managing your watchlist, and discovering new series. MyAnimeList (MAL) and AniList are the two biggest contenders, each with loyal communities and distinct approaches. Here is how they compare.
Interface and Design
AniList wins hands down in the design department. Its modern, customisable interface feels fresh and responsive. Profile pages can be personalised with custom CSS, and the dark mode is excellent. MyAnimeList has a more dated design, though recent updates have improved things. If aesthetics matter to you, AniList is the clear choice.
Database and Content
MyAnimeList has the larger and more established database, with entries going back decades and extensive information on even the most obscure titles. AniList covers manga and light novels alongside anime, and its community-driven approach means new entries are often added quickly. Both sites have comprehensive seasonal anime charts for tracking upcoming releases.
Social Features
AniList has an activity feed similar to social media, where you can see what your friends are watching, share reviews, and interact with the community. MyAnimeList has traditional forums that foster deeper discussions but feel less modern. Both have clubs and groups for specific interests.
API and Integrations
AniList offers a modern GraphQL API that many third-party anime apps and websites use for metadata and tracking. MyAnimeList also has an API but it has historically been less reliable. If you use apps like Taiga, MALSync, or Tachiyomi, check which tracking service they integrate with best.
Our Recommendation
For new anime fans, AniList is the better starting point thanks to its modern design and social features. For long-time anime fans who want the deepest database and established community, MyAnimeList remains the gold standard. Many dedicated fans use both.